The effect of magnetic field on scale deposition of Birjand tap water

Document Type : Technical Note (5 pages)

Authors

1 Assistant Professor, Department of Civil Engineering, School of Engineering, Kharazmi University, Tehran

2 Master of Science student, Civil Engineering – Environmental Engineering, Kharazmi University, Tehran

Abstract

Water magnetization technology and its effect on the chemical and physical properties of water has been one of the controversial topics in two past decades. In this research, the effects of magnetic field on scaling of Birjand tap water studied using Ryznar index and two different pilot scale tests. In the first experiment, to evaluate the hourly changes of remained solids in the porcelain dishes, a pilot is designed so that water of the first tank passed through a magnetic field and then collected in the second tank. After that, TDS of the water was analyzed at 4 modes of without passing, one, three and five times passing through magnet with two replications. In the second experiment, scale deposition of tap water on a humidifier device was investigated. Results showed that the magnetic field didn’t have significant impact on the water chemistry (related to scale deposition) and it made a little change in the Ryznar index. Also, TDS of different samples passed through the magnets was about 850 mg/L and all averages were in the same category of Tukey statistical analysis method. However, sediments formed on the electrodes of the humidifier were less (43% reduction) and softer.

Keywords

Main Subjects


Abdel Tawab RS, Younes MA, Ibrahim AM, Abdel Aziz MM (2011) Testing commercial water magnetizers: a study of TDS and pH. In: Fifteenth International Water Technology Conference, Alexandria, Egypt
Abdo Salehi SE, Banejad H (2009) Create a magnetic field for prevention obstruction in pressure systems when using unusual waters. In: The first international conference on the water crisis. University of Zabol (In Persian)
Ahmadi M, Khashie Siuki A, Shahidi A (2014) Effect of magnetic water and natural clinoptilolite zeolite on growth of green bean (Phaseolus vulgaris L). Iranian Journal of irrigation and Drainage 8(1):216-224 (In Persian)
Ashrafi SF, Naseri AA, Behzad M (2014) investigative of effect of magnetic saturated hydraulic conductivity. science and irrigation engineering (agriculture scientific journal) 36(4):28-19 (In Persian)
Banejad H, Ghahroodi I, IsnaAshari M, Liyagat AM (2013) The interaction of magnetic water and salinity on performance and components of basil plant. Iranian Journal of Irrigation and Drainage 7(2):178-183 (In Persian)
Clesceri LS, Greenberg AE, Eaton AD (1999) Standard Methods for the Examination of Water and Wastewater, 20th Edition. American Public Health Association, American Water Works Association, Water Environment Federation
Dehghani F, Abargouei NS, Qyasvnd A (2009) Effect of magnetic irrigation water on operation of greenhouse cucumber in Yazd. In: Proceeding of the Eleventh Congress of Iran Soil Science:1538-1536 (In Persian)
Gabrielli C, Jaouhari R, Maurin G, Keddam M (2001) Magnetic water treatment for scale prevention. Water Research, 35(13):3249–3259
Gholizadeh M, Arabshahi H, Benam MR (2005) The Effect of Magnetic Field on Scale Prevention in the Industrial Boilers. International Journal of Applied Chemistry 1(1):84-89
Gholizadeh M, Arabshahi H, Saeidi MR, Mahdavi B (2008) The Effect of Magnetic Water on Growth and Quality Improvement of Poultry, Middle-East Journal of Scientific Research 3(3):140-144
Hilal MH, El-Fakhrani YM, Mabrouk SS, Mohamed AI, Ebead BM (2013) Effect of magnetic treatment irrigation water on salt removal from a sandy soil and on the availability of certain nutrients. International Journal of Engineering and Applied Sciences 2(2):36-44
Jiang L, Zhang JL, Li DK (2015) Effects of permanent magnetic field on calcium carbonate scaling of circulating water. Journal of Desalination and Water Treatment 53(5):1275-1285
Khorshidi N, Afshin H, Gholizade M (2004) The effect of Magnetic Water on some of the properties of fresh and hardened concrete. In: First National Congress of Civil Engineering, Sharif University of Technology (In Persian)
Kotb A (2013) Magnetized Water and Memory Meter. Journal of Energy and Power Engineering 5:422-426
Kotb A, Abdel Aziz AL (2013) Scientific investigations on the claims of the magnetic water conditioners. Journal of International Environmental Application and Science 8(3):384-396
Mazlumi S, Heidari S, Mahvi AH, Noori Sepehr M, Khodayari M (2013) Predicting and measuring the amount of  scale deposition in polyethylene pipes with using of deposition and corrosion stability tests and provide effective solutions. Health magazine 4:164-156 (In Persian)
McMahon CA (2009) Investigation of the quality of water treated by magnetic fields. B.S. Thesis, University of Southern Queensland, Faculty of Engineering and Surveying
Mirzaee Sh, Sharifan H (2014) Effect of using sea water in magnetic and non-magnetic sea conditions on germination of barley. First National Conference on Irrigation and water productivity. Irrigation and Drainage Board, Mashhad Ferdowsi University (In Persian)
Mosin O, Ignatov I (2014) Basic concepts of Magnetic Water Treatment. European Journal of Molecular Biotechnology 4(2):72-85
Mostafa GM, Hamed OA, Ba-Mardouf K, Al-Shil K (2001) Studies on effectiveness of magnetic fluid conditioner in control of scale formation in MSF plant. Issued as Technical Report No. TR-3808/EVP 95003
Powell M R (1998) Magnetic water and fuel treatment: Myth, Magic, or Mainstream Science?. Skeptical Inquiry, Volume 22.1
Quinn J, Molden TC, Sanderson CH (1997) Magnetic treatment of water prevents mineral build-up. Journal of Iron and Steel Engineer 74(7):47-53
Smothers KW, Curtiss CD, Gard BT, Strauss RH, Hock VF (2001) Magnetic Water Treatment. U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, Washington, DC Public Works Technical Bulletin No. 420-49-34
White FM (2002) Fluid Mechanics. 5th edition, Tata McGraw Hill Education, 896 Pages
 
 
Volume 13, Issue 3
December 2017
Pages 198-204
  • Receive Date: 16 September 2016
  • Revise Date: 06 February 2017
  • Accept Date: 07 February 2017
  • First Publish Date: 22 November 2017