Iran-Water Resources Research

Iran-Water Resources Research

Investigation of the Effect of Modified Snow Parameters and the Snowmelt Model on Improving Runoff Simulation by the SWAT Model in Zarrineh-rud River Basin

Document Type : Original Article

Authors
1 PhD Student of Water Resource Engineering and Management, College of Civil Water and Environmental Engineering, Shahid Beheshti University, Tehran, Iran.
2 Former Assistant Professor, Water Engineering Group, College of Civil and Environmental Engineering, Tarbiat Modares University, Tehran, Iran.
Abstract
Monitoring snow cover and estimating the resulting snowmelt runoff in mountain areas is highly important. There are mainly two approaches to improve the performance of snowmelt runoff in rainfall-runoff models; improving the snow parameters through observations and modifying the snowmelt module. This study investigates the impact of these approaches on the accuracy of snowmelt runoff using the SWAT model in the mountain basin of Zarineh-rud River, northwest of Iran. Firstly, the snow parameters of SWAT were extracted through the MODIS daily snow cover products and the in-situ snow depth data and were replaced in the model. Secondly, the UBCWM energy balance model was substituted for the original SWAT snowmelt module, which was based on the degree-day method. Results showed that the baseline SWAT model underestimates the runoff at the upstream and downstream hydrometric stations. However, the performance of the model with the modified snow parameters improves at the two stations by 6% and 14% for Nash–Sutcliffe Efficiency (NSE) and 35% and 14% for Kling-Gupta Efficiency (KGE), respectively. On the contrary, using UBCWM in SWAT gives weaker simulations for runoffs at the two stations due to underestimating the peaks and overestimating the snowmelt duration. This study's findings can help achieving more accurate runoff estimations in mountain basins, especially during peak runoffs.
Keywords

Subjects


Abbaspour KC (2011) SWAT-CUP4: SWAT calibration and uncertainty programs–a user manual. Swiss Federal Institute of Aquatic Science and Technology, Eawag
Ahmadzadeh H, Morid S, Delavar M, and Srinivasan R (2016) Using the SWAT model to assess the impacts of changing irrigation from surface to pressurized systems on water productivity and water saving in the Zarrineh Rud catchment. Agricultural Water Management 175:15-28
Debele B, Srinivasan R, and Gosain AK (2010) Comparison of process-based and temperature-index snowmelt modeling in SWAT. Water Resources Management 24(6):1065-1088
Ebrahime H, Ghani A, Malakoti H (2012) Trend of snow cover detection using satellite data from MODIS over snow-rich areas in Iran. Journal of Meteorological Organization 36(79):3-10 (In Persian)
Essery R, Morin S, Lejeune Y, and Menard CB (2013) A comparison of 1701 snow models using observations from an alpine site. Advances in Water Resources 55:131-148
Fassnacht SR, Sexstone GA, Kashipazha AH, Lopez‐Moreno JI, Jasinski MF, Kampf SK, and Von Thaden BC (2015) Deriving snow‐cover depletion curves for different spatial scales from remote sensing and snow telemetry data. Hydrological Processes 30(11):1708-1717
Fattahi E, Moghimi S, khorshidi M (2014) Application of NOAA satellite image for determining the variation of snow cover trend in North-west of Iran. Arid Regions Geographic Studies 4(14):1-10 (In Persian)
Fontaine TA, Cruickshank TS, Arnold JG, and Hotchkiss RH (2002) Development of a snowfall–snowmelt routine for mountainous terrain for the soil water assessment tool (SWAT). Journal of Hydrology 262(1):209-223
Gayathri KD, Ganasri BP, and Dwarakish GS (2015) A Review on Hydrological Models. Aquatic Procedia 4(Icwrcoe):1001–1007
Ghasemfalaki G, Ahmadi H, and Hesari B (2020) Assessment of the impact of climate change and implementing policies on water supply vulnerabilities. Iranian Journal of Irrigation & Drainage 14(3):881-893
Golzari S, Zareabyaneh H, Delavar M, and Mobargaei Dinan N (2020) Performance of SWAT model in quantitative and qualitative simulation of runoff and watershed protective measures in Zarrinehrood Basin. Journal of Water and Environmental Management Research 11(22):111-120 (In Persian)
Goodarzi MR, Zahabiyoun B, Massah Bavani AR, Kamal AR (2012) Performance comparison of three hydrological models SWAT, IHACRES and SIMHYD for the runoff simulation of Gharesou basin. Water and Irrigation Management 2(1):25-40 (In Persian)
Grusson Y, Sun X, Gascoin S, Sauvage S, Raghavan S, Anctil F, and Sachez-Perez JM (2015) Assessing the capability of the SWAT model to simulate snow, snow melt and streamflow dynamics over an alpine watershed. Journal of Hydrology 531:574-588
Hopkinson C, Lowe A, Zawadzki A, and English M (2001) Using oxygen isotope tracers to evaluate & optimise flow components generated by the UBC watershed model in a Mountainous Basin. In Proceedings of the 58th Eastern Snow Conference 14-18
Infante Corona JA (2015) Assimilating merged remote sensing and ground-based snowpack information for streamflow simulation. Doctoral Dissertation, The City College of New York
Kim SB, Shin HJ, Park M, and Kim SJ (2015) Assessment of future climate change impacts on snowmelt and stream water quality for a mountainous high-elevation watershed using SWAT. Paddy and Water Environment 13(4):557-569
Liu Y, Cui G, and Li H (2020) Optimization and application of snow melting modules in SWAT model for the alpine regions of northern China. Water 12(3):636
Mahmudi P, Motamedvaziri B, Hosseini M, Ahmadi H, and Amini A (2021) Study of climate change effects on hydrological processes in Siminehroud and Zarrinehroud watersheds northwest of Iran. Earth Science Informatics 14:965-974
Meng XY, Yu DL, and Liu ZH (2015) Energy balance-based SWAT model to simulate the mountain snowmelt and runoff-taking the application in Juntanghu watershed (China) as an example. Journal of Mountain Science 12(2):368-381
Mirmousavi H, Saboor L (2014) Monitoring the changes of snow cover by using MODIS sensing images at northwest of Iran. Geography and Development Iranian Journal 12(35):181-200 (In Persian)
Morid S, Gosain AK, and Keshari AK (2004) Response of different snowmelt algorithms to synthesized climatic data for runoff simulation. Journal of the Earth and Space Physics 30(1):1-9
Motovilov YG, Gottschalk L, Engeland K, and Rodhe A (1999) Validation of a distributed hydrological model against spatial observations. Agricultural and Forest Meteorology 98:257-277
Naeem UA, Hashmi HN, and Shakir AS (2013) Flow trends in river Chitral due to different scenarios of glaciated extent. KSCE Journal of Civil Engineering 17:244-251
Naserabadi F, Esmali Ouri A, Akbari H, Rostamian R (2016) River flow simulation using SWAT model (Case study: Ghareh Su River in Ardabil Province-Iran). Journal of Watershed Management Research 7(13):50-59 (In Persian)
Neitsch SL, Arnold JG, Kiniry JR, Williams JR, and King KW (2005) Soil and water assessment tool theoretical documentation version 2005. Grassland Soil and Water Research Laboratory Agricultural Research Service Blackland Research Center Texas Agricultural Experiment Station Texas: 494
Norbiato D, Borga M, Degli Esposti S, Gaume E, and Anquetin S (2008) Flash flood warning based on rainfall thresholds and soil moisture conditions: An assessment for gauged and ungauged basins. Journal of Hydrology 362(3):274-290
Nourali M, Ghahraman B, Pourreza Bilondi M, and Davary K (2016) Effect of likelihood function choice for estimating uncertainty of HEC-HMS flood simulation model using Markov Chain Monte Carlo Algorithm. Iran-Water Resources Research 12(3):80-98 (In Persian)
Pandi D, Kothandaraman S, and Kuppusamy M (2021) Hydrological models: a review. International Journal of Hydrology Science and Technology 12(3):223-242
Peker IB and Sorman AA (2021) Application of SWAT using snow data and detecting climate change impacts in the mountainous eastern regions of Turkey. Water 13(14):1982
Rahmani J and Danesh-Yazdi M (2022) Quantifying the impacts of agricultural alteration and climate change on the water cycle dynamics in a headwater catchment of Lake Urmia Basin. Agricultural Water Management 270:107749
Rahvareh M, Motamedvaziri B, Moghaddamnia A, and Moridi A (2023) Modeling runoff management strategies under climate change scenarios using hydrological simulation in the Zarrineh River Basin, Iran. Journal of Water and Climate Change 14(7):2205–2226
Ramage JM and Isacks BL (2003) Interannual variations of snowmelt and refreeze timing on southeast-Alaskan icefields, USA. Journal of Glaciology 49(164):102-116
Rostamian R, Jaleh A, Afyuni M, Mousavi SF, Heidarpour M, Jalalian A, and Abbaspour KC (2008) Application of a SWAT model for estimating runoff and sediment in two mountainous basins in central Iran. Hydrological Sciences Journal 53(5):977-988
Schmugge TJ, Kustas WP, Ritchie JC, Jackson TJ, and Rango A (2002) Remote sensing in hydrology. Advances in Water Resources 25(8):1367-1385
Schulz O and De Jong C (2004) Snowmelt and sublimation: Field experiments and modelling in the High Atlas Mountains of Morocco. Hydrology and Earth System Sciences Discussions 8(6):1076-1089
Taia S, Erraioui L, Arjdal Y, Chao J, El Mansouri B, and Scozzari A (2023) The application of SWAT Model and remotely sensed products to characterize the dynamic of streamflow and snow in a mountainous watershed in the high Atlas. Sensors 23(3):1246
Tobin KJ and Bennett ME (2020) Improving SWAT model calibration using soil MERGE (SMERGE). Water 12(7):2039
Tolson BA and Shoemaker CA (2004) Watershed modeling of the Cannonsville Basin using SWAT2000 Model. Cornell Library Technical Reports and Papers
Tuo Y, Duan Z, Disse M, and Chiogna G (2016) Evaluation of precipitation input for SWAT modeling in Alpine catchment: A case study in the Adige River Basin (Italy). Science of The Total Environment 573:66-82
Wang X and Xie H (2009) New methods for studying the spatiotemporal variation of snow cover based on combination products of MODIS Terra and Aqua. Journal of Hydrology 371(1):192-200
Yazdandoost F, Moradian S, and Izadi A (2020) Evaluation of water sustainability under a changing climate in Zarrineh River Basin, Iran. Water Resources Management 34:4831-4846
Zare M, Azam S, and Sauchyn D (2022) A modified SWAT model to simulate soil water content and soil temperature in cold regions: A case study of the South Saskatchewan River Basin in Canada. Sustainability 14(17):10804
Zhao H, Li H, Xuan Y, Li C, and Ni H (2022) Improvement of the SWAT Model for snowmelt runoff simulation in seasonal snowmelt area using remote sensing data. Remote Sensing 14(22):5823

  • Receive Date 10 May 2023
  • Revise Date 18 July 2023
  • Accept Date 23 July 2023